The innovation deficit in public services: The curious problem of too much efficiency and not enough waste and failure
Jason Potts
ARC Center of Excellence for Creative Industries and Innovation (CCI), Queensland University of Technology; School of Economics, University of Queensland, Brisbane QLD
PP: 34
Abstract
It has long been recognized that government and public sector services suffer an innovation deficit compared to private or market-based services.
This paper argues that this can be explained as an unintended consequence of the concerted public sector drive toward the elimination of waste through efficiency, accountability and transparency. Yet in an evolving economy this can be a false efficiency, as it also eliminates the 'good waste' that is a necessary cost of experimentation. This results in a systematic trade-off in the public sector between the static efficiency of minimizing the misuse of public resources and the dynamic efficiency of experimentation. This is inherently biased against risk and uncertainty and, therein, explains why governments find service innovation so difficult.
In the drive to eliminate static inefficiencies, many political systems have subsequently overshot and stifled policy innovation. I propose, instead, the 'Red Queen' solution of adaptive economic policy.
Keywords
public sector economics, economic evolution, innovation, innovation policy
References
Albury D (2005) Fostering Innovation in Public Services, Public Money and Management 25: 51-56.
Baumol W (2002) The free-market innovation machine. Princeton University Press: Princeton.
Beinhocker E (2006) The origin of wealth: Evolution, complexity and the radical re-making of economics. Harvard Business School Press: Boston.
Bhatta G (2003) Don't just do something, stand there! - Revisiting the issue of risks in innovation in the public sector, The Innovation Journal 8(2).
Buchanan J (2006) Why I, too, am not a conservative. Edward Elgar: Cheltenham.
Burtless G (1995) The case for randomized field trials in economic and policy research, Journal of Economic Perspectives 9: 63-84.
Dodgson M, Gann D and Salter A (2005) Think, Play, Do. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
Dopfer K (ed) (2001) Evolutionary economics: Program and scope. Kluwer: London.
Dopfer K (ed) (2005) Evolutionary foundations of economics. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.
Dopfer K, Foster J and Potts J (2004) Micro meso macro, Journal of Evolutionary Economics 14: 263-279.
Dopfer K and Potts J (2008) The general theory of economic evolution. Routledge: London.
Gallouj F and Weinstein O (1997) Innovation in services, Research Policy 26: 537-556.
Golden O (1990) Innovation in public sector human service programs: The implications of innovation by 'groping along', Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 9: 219-248.
Hartley J (2005) Innovation in governance and public services: Past and present, Public Money and Management 25: 27-34.
Hayek F (1960) Postscript: Why I am not a conservative, in The constitution of liberty. Routledge: London.
Kamarck E (2004) 'Government innovation around the world', Ash Institute for Democratic Governance and Innovation, John F Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University.
Leigh A (2003) Randomized policy trials, Agenda 10: 341-354.
Loasby B (1999) Knowledge, Institutions and Evolution in Economics. Routledge: London.
Metcalfe JS (1998) Evolutionary economics and creative destruction. Routledge: London.
Metcalfe JS and Miles I (2000) Innovation systems in the services sector: Measurement and case study analysis. Kluwer: London.
Miles I (2004) Innovation in services, in Fargerberg J, Mowrey D and Nelson R (eds) Understanding Innovation. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
Mulgan G and Albury D (2003) Innovation in the Public Sector, Strategy Unit, Cabinet Office UK.
Nelson R and Winter S (1982) An evolutionary theory of economic change. Harvard University Press: Cambridge MA.
Newman J, Raine J and Skelcher C (2001) Transforming local government: Innovation and modernization, Public Money and Management 21: 61-70.
OECD (2001) Innovation and Productivity in Services. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development: Paris.
Ormerod P (2005) Why Most Things Fail: Evolution, Extinction and Economics. Faber & Faber: London.
Osbourne S (1998a) Naming the beast: defining and classifying service innovations in social policy, Human Relations 51: 1133-1154.
Osbourne S (1998b) Voluntary organizations and innovation in public services. Routledge: London.
Parsons W (2006) Innovation in the public sector: Spare tyres and fourth plinths. The Innovation Journal: The Public Sector Innovation Journal 11(2): Article 1.
Pelikan P and Wegner G (2003) The Evolutionary Analysis of Economic Policy. Edward Elgar: Cheltenham.
Potts J (2000) The new evolutionary microeconomics: complexity, competence and adaptive behaviour. Edward Elgar: Cheltenham.
Riddle D (1986) Service led growth. Praeger: New York.
Ridley M (1995) The Red Queen: Sex and the evolution of human nature. Penguin Books: New York.
Romer P (1994) The origins of endogenous growth, Journal of Economic Perspectives 8: 3-22.
Rubin P (2002) Darwinian politics: The evolutionary origin of freedom. Rutgers University Press: New Brunswick NJ.
Schumpeter J (1945) Capitalism, socialism and democracy. Allen & Unwin: London.
Tether B (2003) The sources and aims of innovation in services: variety within and between sector, Economics of Innovation and New Technology 12: 481-505.
Walker R (2003) Evidence on the management of public services innovation, Public Money and Management 23: 93-102.
Walker R (2006) Innovation type and diffusion: An empirical analysis of local government, Public Administration 84: 311-335.
eContent Home
