Archives
The GSM standard and Nokia as an incubating entrant
Christopher Palmberg
The Research Institute of the Finnish Economy (ETLA), Lönnrotinkatu, Helsinki, Finland
Olli Martikainen
Department of Information Processing, Sciences, University of Oulu, Finland
Abstract
The Finnish telecom industry is largely based on the unprecedented success of Nokia. The GSM standard is interesting in this context. It is at present the most widely diffused telecom standard in the world, and largely accounts for the international breakthrough and market leadership of Nokia. Moreover, the GSM was discontinuous to the incumbent equipment suppliers compared to previous standards. This paper identifies the nature and consequences of these discontinuities, and analyses the conditions and processes that contributed to Nokia's ability to successfully enter the market ahead of incumbents in the industry. We suggest that Nokia was an 'incubating entrant' by possessing latent competencies in discontinuous GSM-related technologies, even though it was a new entrant in the field of cellular systems. We also suggest that this largely explains Nokia's subsequent success, and question some underlying assumptions of the literature on technology competition and industrial dynamics.
Keywords
Nokia, GSM, discontinuity, incumbency, entry
References
Abernathy, W and Utterback, J (1978) Patterns of industrial innovation. Technology Review no. 80, 41-47
Adner, R and Zemsky, P (2002) Strategy Dynamics through a Demand-Based Lens: The Evolution of Market Boundaries, Resource Rents, and Competitive Positions. INSEAD Working Paper Series 2003/01/SM
Alanko, J (1990) Partitioning of layered mobile communications software. Licentiate thesis, University of Oulu. Department of Electrical Engineering
Anderson, P and Tushman, M (1997) Managing through cycles of technological change. In Tushman, M and Anderson, P (eds.) Managing strategic innovation and change - a collection of readings
Bach, D (2000) International Cooperation and the Logic of Networks: European and the Global System of Mobile Communications (GSM). BRIE Working Paper 139
Bekkers, R and Smits, J (1997) Mobile telecommunications: standards, regulation and applications. Boston: Artech House Publishers
Bower, J and Christensen, C (1995) Disruptive Technologies: Catching the Wave. Harvard Business Review, vol.17, issue 1, 43-5.
Christensen, C (1997) The Innovators Dilemma. Boston MA: Harvard Business School Press
Dosi, G (1988) The nature of the innovation process. In Dosi, G et al. (eds.) Technical Change and Economic Theory. Pinter Publishers
Dunning, J and Boyd, G (eds.)(2003) Alliance Capitalism and Corporate Management - Entrepreneurial Cooperation in Knowledge Based Economies. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar
Ehrnberg, E (1996) Technological discontinuities and industrial dynamics. Chalmers University Press (PhD thesis)
Foss, N (1997) Resources, firms and strategy - A reader in the resource-based perspective. Oxford University Press
Freeman, C (1994) The Economic of Technological Change - A Critical Survey. Research Policy, vol.20,no.5, 499-514.
GSM Association (2003) www.gsmworld.com/about/history
Hommen, L and Manninen, E (2003) The Global System for Mobile Telecommunications (GSM): Second Generation. In Edquist, C (ed.) The Internet and Mobile Telecommunications System of Innovation. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar
Häikiö, M (2001) Nokia Oyj:n historia, Sturm und Drang, suurkaupoilla eurooppalaiseksi elektroniikkayritykseksi 1983-1991. Edita
Koivusalo, M (1995) Kipinästä tuli syttyy - Suomalaisen radiopuhelinteollisuuden kehitys ja tulevaisuuden haasteet. Jyväskylä: Gummerus Kirjapaino
Manninen, A (2002) Elaboration of NMT and GSM standards - From Idea to Market. PhD thesis. Studia Historica Jyväskyläensia 60
Palmberg, C (1997) Public technology procurement as a policy instrument - Selected cases from the Finnish telecommunications industry. VTT Group for Technology Studies Working Papers Series, no.28/97
Palmberg, C (1998) Industrial transformation through public technology procurement? The case of the Finnish telecommunications industry. Meddelanden från Ekonomisk-Statsvetenskapliga Fakulteten vid Åbo Akademi, Ser. A:494 (Licentiate thesis)
Palmberg, C (2002) Technological systems and competent procurers - the transformation of Nokia and the Finnish telecom industry revisited. Telecommunications Policy 26, 129-148
Palmberg, C and Martikainen, O (2003) Overcoming a technological discontinuity - The case of the Finnish telecom industry and the GSM. ETLA Discussion papers no. 855
Pulkkinen, M (1997) The breakthrough of Nokia Mobile Phones. The Helsinki School of Economics and Business Administration, Series A:122
Rosenbloom, R and Christensen, C (1994) Technological Discontinuities, Organizational Capabilities, and Strategic Commitments. Industrial and Corporate Change, vol.3, no.3. 655-685
Rothaermel, F (2000) Technological discontinuities and the nature of competition. Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, vol.12, no.2,149-160
Schumpeter, J (1911/1968) The Theory of Economic Development. English translation 1968. Cambridge: Harvard University Press
Teece, D (1986) Profiting from technological innovation: implications for integration, collaboration, licensing and public policy. Research Policy, vol.15, no.6, 285-305
Tushman, M and Anderson, P (1986) Technological discontinuities and organizational environments. Administrative Science Quarterly, 31: 439-465
Utterback, J (1994) Mastering the dynamics of innovation. Boston: Harvard Business School Press
Ward, P.T and Mellor S. J (1985) Structured development for real-time systems. Volumes 1-3. New York: Yourdon Press
eContent Home